Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani: Trustworthy, and it was said: He had Companionship
al-Dhahabi: It was said: He had Companionship
al-Mizzi: Disagreement on his Companionship
Abd al-Rahman ibn Muhammad ibn Mandah al-Asbahani: He had Companionship
Muhammad ibn Ishaq ibn Mandah al-Asbahani: He had Companionship
Yahya ibn Ma'in: Trustworthy Trustworthy