Abu Ahmad ibn Adi al-Jarjani: He narrates falsehoods from al-Firyabi and others. He has a hadith that is not preserved. He is either negligent and does not know what comes out of his head, or he is deliberate, for I have seen from him more than one hadith that is not preserved
Amer Hassan Sabri: Ibn Adi accused him of weakness in his narrations due to his poor memorization and lack of piety, but he did not accuse him of lying