Amr ibn Utab عمرو بن عتاب

Name: Amr ibn Utab

Fame: Amr ibn Utab al-Hadrami

Lineage: Kufi, Hadhrami

Rank: Abandoned Hadith Narrator

Lived in: Hadhramaut, Kufa

Abu Ahmad ibn Adi al-Jurjani: It is said that he was a Murji'ite

Abu Ja'far al-'Uqayli: His hadith narration is questionable

Abu Hatim al-Razi: He is a rejected hadith narrator and was a Murji'ite

Abu Hatim ibn Hibban al-Bustī: His hadith narration is very rejected despite the scarcity of his narrations. He narrates from 'Asim what is not from his hadith. If he heard from 'Asim what he narrated from him, then perhaps he heard it during 'Asim's confusion because 'Asim became confused at the end of his life. If he heard from him what he narrated before the confusion, then relying on his narration is invalid regarding what he narrates uniquely that is not from his hadith

Ibn Hajar al-'Asqalani: A weak Kufi narrator

al-Daraqutni: Weak, and once: From the Sheikhs of the Shia

al-Dhahabi: He is not reliable, and he has been accused. He said about a hadith: This hadith is rejected and the problem is from him

Muhammad ibn Isma'il al-Bukhari: A rejected hadith narrator, and once: His hadith narration is questionable