Abu al-Faraj ibn al-Jawzi: He mentioned a fabricated hadith for him, and said I do not see the harm in it except from him, and accused him of fabricating another hadith
Abu Bakr al-Barqani: Every hadith of al-Naqqash is rejected, and once: There is no authentic hadith in his exegesis
Abu Amr al-Dani: He praised him
Ibn 'Iraq: He was accused of lying and fabrication
Al-Khatib al-Baghdadi: In his hadiths, there are rejected narrations with famous chains
Al-Daraqutni: He criticized him
Al-Dhahabi: He became the sheikh of the Quran reciters in his time despite his weakness, and once: He mentioned a hadith for him and said: I think he is the one who fabricated it, and once: Truthful, those who accused him of lying made a mistake, but he is not infallible, and once: Famous, he was accused of lying, and he came in his interpretation with errors and scandals, and he is exemplary in the readings
Talha ibn Muhammad al-Shahid: He lies in hadith and most of his narrations are stories
Abd al-Hayy ibn al-'Imad al-Hanbali: The exegete, the author of books on exegesis and readings, and despite his greatness in knowledge and his nobility, he is weak and his hadith are abandoned
Abd al-Karim ibn Muhammad al-Rafai: He was very knowledgeable and narrated many hadiths