Abu al-Abbas al-Siraj: He does not intentionally lie, but he is attributed with delusion
Abu al-Faraj ibn al-Jawzi: Weak
Abu Abd Allah al-Hakim al-Nishapuri: He was well-versed in hearing, seeking, and narrating Hadith, coming from a household of Hadith, asceticism, and Sufism. He authored a Tafsir, Sunan, and history for Sufis
al-Hasan ibn Ali al-Daqqaq: Perhaps silence is more appropriate for him
al-Khatib al-Baghdadi: He was interested in the accounts of Sufis and authored for them Sunan, Tafsir, and history. There are things unique to him in the heart. And once: His status among the people of his town was great, and his position in his group was high. He was also a skilled Hadith scholar who gathered Sheikhs, biographies, and chapters
al-Dhahabi: He is not strong in Hadith, and once: They spoke about him and he is not reliable, and once: In his works are fabricated Hadiths and stories, and in the truths of his Tafsir: Things that are not acceptable at all, some Imams counted them as from the heresy of the Batiniyya
Muhammad ibn Yusuf al-Qattan: He was not trustworthy, and once: He used to fabricate Hadiths for the Sufis