Ahmad ibn Muhammad al-Atiqi: He was known for a lot of fabrication
Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani: One of the weak narrators
Ibn 'Iraq: A liar who fabricates hadith
Al-Khatib al-Baghdadi: They wrote from him then repented of his lies and tore up his hadith, and he used to fabricate hadiths for the Shi'a
Al-Daraqutni: He accused him of fabrication and lying about hearing from Ibn al-Furat
Tamam ibn Muhammad al-Razi: He described him as having good memory
Hamzah al-Daqqaq: He used to fabricate hadith and I wrote from him and he had an appearance and dignity
Abd ibn Ahmad al-Harawi: He sat with the Shi'a and filled them with hadiths mentioning the slander of the Companions, and they accused him of distorting and fabricating
Ubaydullah ibn Ahmad al-Azhari: He used to mix up and spoke ill of him, saying he was a lying deceiver I never saw any origin for him