Abu Abd Allah al-Hakim al-Naysaburi: Companion
Ahmad ibn Salih al-Jili: Trustworthy
Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani: Trustworthy, arrived in Medina five days after the Prophet's death
al-Mizzi: Differing in his companionship
Muhammad ibn Sa'd, the scribe of al-Waqidi: Trustworthy, narrating few hadiths
Yahya ibn Ma'in: The people of Medina narrate from him, it is likely that he had companionship, and once, in a narration by Ibn Mahriz: He did not have companionship