Abu Ahmad ibn Adi Al-Jurjani: I hope there is nothing wrong with him
Abu Hatim Ar-Razi: Similar to unknown
Abu Hatim ibn Hibban Al-Busti: He mentioned him in Ath-Thiqat
Abu Nuaym Al-Fadl ibn Dukin: Hubayra used to permit killing the wounded with Al-Mukhtar
Ahmad ibn Hanbal: A righteous man, there is nothing wrong with his Hadith, he is better in integrity than others, and once: He is dearer to us than Haritha Al-A'war
Ahmad ibn Shuayb An-Nasa'i: Not strong, and once: I hope there is nothing wrong with him, and he narrated another Munkar Hadith
Ahmad ibn Salih Al-Jili: Thiqah
Ibrahim ibn Yaqub Al-Jawzajani: He was chosen to finish off the wounded on the Day of Khazir
Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani: There is nothing wrong with him, and he was criticized for Shiism
Adh-Dhahabi: Reliable
Abd Ar-Rahman ibn Yusuf ibn Kharash: Weak
Muhammad ibn Ismail Al-Bukhari: He used to finish off the wounded with Al-Mukhtar
Muhammad ibn Sa'd Kathib Al-Waqidi: Known, and not that
Yahya ibn Ma'in: Unknown