Abu Ahmad bin Adi Al-Jurjani: I saw the people of Iraq agreeing on his weakness, and he is not known for any Munkar Hadith, but they weakened him because he did not meet those who narrate Hadith
Abu Al-Abbas bin Uqdah Al-Kufi: He did not narrate from him because of his weakness
Abu Hatim Al-Razi: He is not strong
Abu Hatim bin Habban Al-Basti: He may have made mistakes, but I did not see in his Hadith anything that should make one abandon him and follow the path of those who are discredited
Abu Abd Allah Al-Hakim Al-Naysaburi: He is not strong according to them
Abu Ya'la Al-Khalili: There are no Munkar Hadiths in his narration, but he narrated from the elders, so they accused him because of that
Ibn Abi Hatim Al-Razi: I wrote from him but refrained from narrating Hadith from him because people criticized him
Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani: Weak, but his hearing of Al-Sirah is Sahih
Al-Daraqutni: He is fine, and our Sheikhs differed about him, and he was not from the people of Hadith. And in Al-Hakim's questions, he said: His hearing was from the books of his father, and his father was trustworthy
Al-Dhahabi: He commented on Al-Hakim by saying: Weak
Al-Saji bin Yahya: Trustworthy
Muttin Al-Hazarmi: He used to lie