al-Daraqutni: Shaykh Salih
al-Dhahabi: Thiqah in Hadith and Quran reading, and once: He was righteous, trustworthy, and a scholar
Talhah ibn Muhammad al-Shahid: A righteous man
Muhammad ibn al-Jazari al-Muqri: He was knowledgeable about the letters of Hamza, and he was a precise, pious, and trustworthy scholar